Freight payment terms
On a voyage charter the charterer pays freight for carrying the cargo. Two questions decide how safe that money is for the owner. First, when is the freight earned, so that the owner keeps it even if something goes wrong later? Second, when must it be paid? They are separate questions, the charterparty usually answers them in separate words, and a recap that only says "freight 95 percent within 3 banking days" has answered only the second one.
The rule when the charterparty says nothing
Under English law, freight is earned when the cargo is delivered at the destination. If the ship sinks on the way and the cargo is lost, no freight is due. Damaged cargo that is still the cargo described in the contract still earns full freight, and the cargo owner must claim the damage separately. The charterer cannot simply deduct a cargo claim from the freight.
This default puts the risk of a total loss on the owner. That is why almost every voyage charter moves the moment of earning earlier, to loading.
Deemed earned on loading
A typical clause says freight is "deemed earned as cargo is loaded, discountless and non-returnable, vessel and/or cargo lost or not lost". Each part does a job:
- Deemed earned on loading. The right to freight exists from the moment the cargo is on board, even though the voyage has not started.
- Discountless. The charterer may not reduce the freight for its own claims against the owner. Commissions agreed in the charterparty still come off.
- Non-returnable, lost or not lost. If the ship or the cargo is lost after loading, the owner keeps the freight already paid and can still collect any part not yet paid.
English courts have held that freight earned this way survives the loss of the ship and even the end of the contract. The charterer carries the risk of loss instead, which is why prudent charterers and cargo owners insure the freight together with the cargo.
GENCON 2022, the BIMCO general voyage charter, takes this approach. Freight other than lump sum freight is earned progressively as the cargo is loaded. Lump sum freight is earned only on completion of loading. In both cases freight is non-returnable if the ship or cargo is lost.
When the money must arrive
Earning gives the owner the right. The payment term sets the date. The common patterns are:
| Wording | What it means | Who it favours |
|---|---|---|
| Prepaid | Full freight paid before or on signing bills of lading | Owner |
| Within N banking days of signing and releasing bills of lading | Usually 3 to 5 banking days after loading is complete and the bills are issued | Owner |
| BBB, before breaking bulk | Paid before discharge starts | Both, depending on route |
| On right and true delivery | Paid after the cargo is delivered | Charterer |
| 95 percent and balance | Most paid early, the rest after discharge when demurrage and other items are settled | Shared |
A banking day is a day the banks are open in the place of payment, so weekends and bank holidays in that country do not count. On a 3 banking day term, bills released on a Friday afternoon may not need to be paid until the following Wednesday.
Releasing matters as much as signing. Many owners will not release original bills of lading until freight is received. If the charterer needs the bills to sell the cargo or open a letter of credit, this gives the owner a strong position.
BBB, and why the exact moment can matter
BBB means the freight is due before the ship starts to discharge. It sounds simple, but a charterer can try to delay "breaking bulk" by not giving discharge instructions. In a 2016 English case, a tanker arrived in Germany with freight unpaid and no instructions to discharge. The court read the clause, which let the owner refuse to start discharge until paid, as making the freight due when the ship had arrived and was available to the charterer. The freight was therefore a debt, not a claim for damages. That difference matters: an owner recovering a debt does not have to prove a loss or reduce it.
If BBB is used, it is safer to tie the date to something the owner controls, such as notice of readiness at the discharge port, and to say plainly that the owner need not discharge until payment arrives.
Freight prepaid and freight collect bills of lading
The charterparty is between owner and charterer. The bill of lading travels with the cargo to the receiver. A bill marked freight prepaid tells the receiver that freight is not its problem, and the owner usually cannot then demand freight from the receiver. A bill marked freight collect or "as per charterparty" keeps the receiver in the chain. GENCON 2022 allows the charterer to demand "freight paid" bills only once the freight has been paid in full. An owner who issues freight prepaid bills before the money arrives gives away its security.
A worked example
Voyage charter, illustrative figures only.
Cargo 30,000 mt
Freight rate US$40 per mt
Gross freight US$1,200,000
Address comm. 3.75% -45,000
Freight due US$1,155,000
Terms: 95% within 3 banking days of signing and releasing B/L,
balance 5% within 30 days of completion of discharge,
together with demurrage or less despatch.
First payment 95% of 1,155,000 1,097,250
Balance 5% of 1,155,000 57,750
plus demurrage, less despatch
The balance is where most arguments sit, because it is paid after the laytime statement is agreed. A charterer who disputes the demurrage often holds back the balance as well. Keep the two items in separate invoices so that an argument about demurrage does not delay freight that is clearly due.
What the owner can do when freight is not paid
- Lien on cargo. At common law the owner has a lien on the cargo for freight due on delivery: the right to keep the cargo until paid. A contractual lien clause can extend this to deadfreight, demurrage and other sums. See liens, cesser and deadfreight.
- Holding the bills of lading. Not releasing original bills until freight arrives is often the most practical security.
- Suspending performance. GENCON 2022 lets the owner suspend performance for unpaid freight, deadfreight or demurrage and, after a notice period, end the contract or discharge at any port.
- Claiming the debt. Freight that is due is a debt and can be claimed in full, usually in arbitration under the charterparty.
A lien only works while the owner still controls the cargo. Once freight prepaid bills are issued or the cargo is delivered, the security is gone. Decide the payment terms with that in mind, and write them into the fixture recap word for word.
References
- Low & Partners, Law of the carriage of goods by sea, part 6. lowpartners.com
- Steamship Mutual, Unpaid freight: a debt or claim in damages?, 2016. steamshipmutual.com
- West of England P&I Club, The new GENCON 2022 charterparty, 2023. westpandi.com
- BIMCO, GENCON 2022, 2022. bimco.org
Related
Neptune Atlas
Chartering software for a broking desk, covering the whole cycle: the world merchant fleet, position lists, cargo enquiries, fixtures, laytime and demurrage, and who to write to. Every paid plan starts with 7 free days. A card is needed to start them, and cancelling before they end costs nothing.
Try 7 days free Ship chartering software for brokers What each plan includes