Neptune Atlas logo Neptune Atlas

Documents

Bills of lading

·

A bill of lading does three different jobs at the same time. No other shipping document does this. First, it is a receipt for the goods. Second, it is evidence of a contract of carriage. Third, it is a document of title. That means the piece of paper controls who may collect the cargo at the other end. Almost every argument about a bill of lading happens because someone treats one of these three jobs as if it were another.

The three functions, and why they come apart

A receipt. The bill records what was put on the ship: the quantity, the condition the goods appeared to be in, their marks, and the date of shipment. Freight and laytime are worked out from this figure, not from the charterparty figure. So it matters for business long before anyone has a dispute.

Evidence of the contract. Note the word "evidence". The shipper and the carrier usually made their contract before the bill was printed, so between the two of them the bill is proof of the contract terms rather than the contract itself. A third party who later buys the goods and receives the bill was not there when the deal was made, and for that holder the bill is the contract.

A document of title. Holding the original bill counts as holding the cargo. So when the bill passes to someone else, the right to demand the cargo passes too. This is what makes it possible to sell a cargo while it is still at sea. It is also the whole reason letters of credit (a bank's promise to pay against documents) work.

A charterparty (the contract to hire the ship) makes the second job more complex. When the shipper is also the charterer, the bill is usually only a receipt in the shipper's hands, because the charterparty is the contract between those two. Once the same bill is endorsed (signed over) to a receiver, it becomes a contract of carriage on its own terms in the receiver's hands. So one document has two legal roles, and the person who holds it decides which role applies.

Words on the face that change the value

DistinctionWhat depends on it
Shipped versus received for shipment A shipped bill says the goods are on board. A received bill only says the carrier has the goods. Letters of credit usually ask for a shipped bill. A bank can reject a received bill dated before loading.
Clean versus claused A clean bill has no note saying the goods or their packing were damaged. A claused bill repeats any such note from the mate's receipt (the ship officer's record of what was loaded). Banks want clean bills. So masters are always under pressure to sign a clean bill even when the mate's receipt has a note.
Order bill versus straight bill An order bill is made out "to order" and can be passed on by endorsement. A straight bill names one consignee (receiver) and cannot be passed on. Courts have heard cases on whether the original must still be shown to collect cargo under a straight bill. The safe answer in practice is yes.
Bill of lading versus sea waybill A waybill is a receipt and evidence of the contract, but not a document of title. So nobody needs to show it at discharge. It is the right document for a cargo that will not be sold at sea. It is the wrong one for a cargo that will be.

Sometimes a bill shows a shipment date that is not the real date. This is not a small administrative change. It is a false document that a bank and a buyer will rely on. A shipowner's liability insurance does not cover it at all.

Who is the carrier

The bill names a carrier, but it can be hard to work out who that is. When a master signs a bill, it usually binds the shipowner; when a charterer's agent signs for the charterer as carrier, it binds the charterer instead. Bill forms include an "identity of carrier" clause or a "demise" clause to settle this in advance, although people who claim for cargo usually sue both parties anyway. The practical point is simpler: the charterparty decides who may sign bills and on whose behalf, so settle it in the recap (the written summary of the deal), not at the load port.

The charterparty bill and its incorporation clause

Most dry cargo bills are issued under a charterparty and say so. They have a line that brings in (incorporates) the charterparty's terms. General words of incorporation bring in terms that relate to carrying the goods. So laytime and freight terms come across easily. An arbitration clause does not. Under English law, the bill needs express words to bring the arbitration clause in. A bill that incorporates "all terms of the charterparty" will usually not include it.

The other half of the same problem is the clause paramount. This clause brings a carriage convention into the bill. Which set of rules it brings in, and how that changes the carrier's liability, is covered in the Hague-Visby, Hamburg and Rotterdam Rules.

Delivering without the original

Very often the cargo arrives before the paperwork. The bills are still passing through banks, while the ship waits at the discharge berth and demurrage (a daily charge for delay) keeps adding up. The industry's answer is a letter of indemnity. The receiver or charterer asks the owner to deliver the cargo without the original bill. In return, they promise to cover any loss the owner suffers.

People new to the trade often miss the insurance point. Ordinary P&I club cover (the owner's liability insurance) excludes delivering cargo without an original bill. Taking a letter of indemnity does not bring that cover back. The letter takes the club's place. So the owner has swapped a mutual insurer for the credit of whoever signed the letter. The International Group publishes standard wordings for exactly this reason: the wording and the signer are the only protection there is. The same is true for delivery at a port that is not the one on the bill, and for switch bills (new bills issued to replace the first set).

Electronic bills

Technology was never the problem with an electronic bill of lading. The problem was the law. A document of title depends on possession, and the law thinks of possession in terms of physical things. The UNCITRAL Model Law on Electronic Transferable Records, adopted in 2017, sets out when someone can possess an electronic record. The United Kingdom passed its own version in the Electronic Trade Documents Act 2023. That does not cover the whole world. An electronic bill only works where every country on its route accepts it.

What to check on a real bill

A bill of lading is the one document in a fixture that a stranger will rely on months later, without talking to anyone who was there. That is why a mistake on its face costs much more than a mistake anywhere else in the file.

References

Hague-Visby, Hamburg and Rotterdam RulesOne set of rules covers most world trade, one is in force only in minor trading nations, one is not in force at all, and the oldest is still law in the United States. Liens, cesser and deadfreightProving the claim is the easier part. These clauses decide whether an owner can actually collect the money. General averageA loss caused on purpose to one party to save everyone is shared by all of them. That is why a cargo owner who did nothing wrong can receive a demand for money. Charterparty formsNobody writes a charterparty from a blank page. People name a printed form, change it, and then disagree about which part of the document applies. What a ship can actually liftA 58,000 deadweight ship does not lift 58,000 tonnes, and at a shallow berth it may not lift 52,000. The sums, written out step by step.

Neptune Atlas

Neptune Atlas works out laytime from the quantity really loaded. That is the bill of lading figure, not the charterparty figure. It is recorded against the fixture with the statement of facts. Neptune Atlas does not issue bills of lading or hold originals. The carrier, or someone acting for the carrier, signs the bill at the load port, and the bill stays where the trade puts it. Every paid plan starts with 7 free days. A card is needed to start them, and cancelling before they end costs nothing.

Try 7 days free Ship chartering software for brokers What each plan includes