Flag states and open registries
A ship's flag is the country where it is registered. That registration decides whose law applies on board, whose surveys and certificates the ship carries, and whose consulate it can turn to for help. A flag is a legal fact, not a reputation, and it tells a broker much less about an operator than most brokers think.
What a flag actually is
Registration puts a ship on one country's register and gives it that country's nationality. Three consequences follow, and there are no others:
- Jurisdiction. On the high seas, the flag state's law applies on board, and the flag state is responsible for investigating accidents and for the ship's conduct. In port, the port state's law applies as well, and port state control enforces it.
- Certificates. The safety, pollution, load line, tonnage and safety management certificates are issued by the flag state or, much more often, by a classification society acting on its behalf as a "recognised organisation".
- Protection. Nationality gives the ship access to diplomatic and consular help, and it is what stops the ship from being stateless. A ship that uses two flags, choosing whichever suits it, is treated as having neither.
Note what the flag does not decide. The law that governs the charterparty is whatever the contract says, usually English law with arbitration in London, and it has nothing to do with where the ship is registered. Owners and charterers regularly fix a Panama-flagged ship under English law, and neither side sees any problem in it.
The genuine link, and what it does not require
The law of the sea requires a "genuine link" between a country and the ships that fly its flag. The convention does not define the phrase, and it has never been read to mean that the owner must be a citizen of that country. What it does require is that the flag state really exercises control over administrative, technical and social matters: that it carries out surveys, certifies seafarers, investigates accidents and keeps a proper register.
So the fair test of a flag is how well its administration works, not the nationality of the shareholders. Some very small countries run strict registries, and some large national ones do not.
Open registries are ordinary
An open registry accepts owners of any nationality, and usually asks only for a locally registered company to hold the title to the ship. Owners use open registries for company structure, for flexibility in hiring crew, for lower fees, and often simply because the registry is available at any hour, for example at three in the morning when a certificate must be signed before a ship can sail.
This is almost universal in deep sea trading, and on its own it proves nothing. The largest open registries carry some of the best-run fleets in the world and some of the worst, because they carry most of the fleet. "Flag of convenience" is a term from the trade union side of the industry, and the lists kept under that name are a political and labour-relations tool rather than a technical one. Judge the operator by its record: inspection history, technical manager, class, age and accident record. The flag is a weak guide to all of these.
The flags on the register
These are the twelve most common flags among the ships Neptune Atlas holds, with the kind of register each one is:
| Flag | Hulls | Kind of register |
|---|---|---|
| Panama | 7,739 | Open |
| Liberia | 6,409 | Open |
| Indonesia | 5,756 | National, with domestic trade strongly reserved for its own ships |
| Marshall Islands | 5,209 | Open |
| China | 5,194 | National |
| United States | 4,416 | National, with domestic trade strongly reserved for its own ships |
| Singapore | 3,763 | Open to foreign owners under conditions |
| Russia | 3,761 | National |
| Japan | 3,292 | National |
| Malta | 2,544 | Open |
| Norway | 2,301 | National, with a second international register alongside |
| Netherlands | 2,107 | National |
Keep two points in mind when you read the table. It counts every type of ship on file, including tugs and fishing boats, so a country with a large coastal fleet ranks higher here than its deep sea fleet alone would put it. And it counts what has been collected, not the whole world fleet.
Ships with a flag, out of 101,900 in the register. Flag is one of the most complete fields there is, more complete than deadweight, which only 75,596 ships have. If a search has to fall back on something, the flag is usually there.
What the flag changes for a fixture
- Certificates and conventions. The international conventions the flag state has signed decide which certificates the ship holds. Charterers, terminals and insurers check for them.
- Crewing and manning. The flag sets the minimum safe manning (the smallest crew allowed), decides which seafarer certificates it will accept or endorse, and on some national registers requires the master or part of the crew to be its own citizens. That affects both costs and recruitment.
- Sanctions and trading limits. Some flags limit who will deal with the ship: some charterers, banks that finance the cargo and insurers will refuse it, and some port authorities will not accept it at all. This is the one area where the flag is decisive rather than just a signal, and it is the reason to check it first.
- Cabotage. In a number of countries, domestic shipping is reserved for ships under the national flag. For those cargoes the flag is not one factor in the decision. It decides the matter alone.
- Port state control exposure. Inspection regimes include the flag's record in a ship risk profile, which affects how often the ship is boarded. Across 364,256 inspections of 44,764 ships, 2.82% ended in detention, with an average of 4.51 deficiencies per inspection. The flag is one factor in that profile, next to age, type, class and the company's own record.
- Labour convention compliance. Wages, rest hours, repatriation and seafarer welfare are enforced against the flag state's obligations and checked by port state control. A detention on these grounds delays a ship just as much as a structural one.
- Tonnage tax and fees. Registration charges, yearly tonnage dues and access to a tonnage tax system differ by country, and that is a large part of why an owner chooses one register over another.
Whitelists and greylists move
The regional inspection regimes publish performance lists that rank flags by their detention record over a rolling period of several years. Broadly, there is a white list of better performers, a grey list in the middle and a black list at the bottom. These lists really do affect how often a ship is boarded. They are recalculated every year, though, and flags move between them, so check the current list when it matters instead of relying on memory. Also be clear about what they measure: the results of inspections on the fleet that happens to fly that flag. That says as much about the fleet as about the registry.
Reflagging, and the key it breaks
Ships change flag when they are sold, when a company is restructured, when they move into a trade that needs a different register, or simply to save money. The change is routine, but its effect on data is not.
When a ship is reflagged, it gets a new port of registry, a new official number, a new call sign and a new MMSI (its radio identity number), because the first three digits of an MMSI identify the flag state. The IMO number never changes for the life of the ship. So any record keyed on something other than the IMO number quietly splits one ship into two the moment it changes flag. MMSI is the field most often used for that purpose, because it is the one AIS provides. It is exactly nine digits long, it is reassigned, and the same data feeds also carry inland ENI numbers and shortened values.
The IMO number has its own problems: 5,900 numbers on file that came from AIS looked like IMO numbers but were not, which is why it is worth checking the check digit before you trust one. A change of flag also comes with a change of name more often than not, and 11,869 ships in the inspection history were inspected under more than one name. Neither the name nor the flag is the ship.
One point deserves to be stated clearly: a change of flag does not wipe a ship's inspection record. The detention history stays with the ship through its IMO number, and a port state control officer can see it whatever name and port are painted on the stern.
Where it lands in a chartering decision
Check the flag early, because sanctions and trading restrictions are a hard filter and easy to apply. After that, most of the time, you can set it aside. A fixture is decided by the rate, the position, the laycan, the ship's description, its gear and whether the owner does what it agreed. A well-run ship on an open register is still a well-run ship, and a badly run ship under a respected national flag is still badly run. The flag tells you which rules a ship operates under, not how well it follows them.
References
- United Nations, United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea, Part VII, 1982. Article 91 on nationality of ships and article 94 on the duties of the flag State. un.org
- IMO, Registration of ships and fraudulent registration matters. imo.org
- Paris MoU, Performance Lists, the white, grey and black list of flags. parismou.org
- Tokyo MoU, Performance Lists. tokyo-mou.org
- International Transport Workers’ Federation, Flags of convenience. itfglobal.org
- International Telecommunication Union, Table of Maritime Identification Digits. The MID that forms the first three digits of an MMSI. itu.int
Related
Neptune Atlas
Neptune Atlas has a flag for 101,608 of the 101,900 ships in the register and links every record to the IMO number, so a change of flag updates a field instead of creating a second ship. Flag appears next to deadweight, type, age and position in a tonnage search, and next to the inspection history when you open a ship. Every paid plan starts with 7 free days. A card is needed to start them, and cancelling before they end costs nothing.
Try 7 days free Ship chartering software for brokers What each plan includes