Contracts of affreightment (COA)
A contract of affreightment (COA) is a promise to carry a total quantity of cargo between agreed ports over an agreed period, at an agreed freight. It does not name a ship. Each shipment is carried as its own voyage, and the owner chooses which ship to send each time. For a charterer with a steady flow of cargo, it fixes the freight cost for a year or more. For an owner, it is assured employment for the fleet.
What a COA fixes, and what it leaves open
When the COA is signed, the parties agree:
- The total quantity. For example 600,000 tonnes of coal, 10 percent more or less in charterers' option.
- The period, for example twelve months, and how the shipments are spread across it.
- The size of each shipment, for example about 55,000 tonnes, 10 percent more or less in owners' option.
- The load and discharge ports or ranges, the freight rate, laytime, demurrage and the other voyage terms.
- The type of ship the owner may nominate: size, age, gear, class and any terminal approvals.
What is left open is the detail of each shipment: the exact laycan (the dates the ship can start loading), the exact quantity within the tolerance, and the ship. These are set later by nominations.
How a shipment is nominated
The usual sequence has two steps:
- The charterer nominates the cargo. Quantity, load port, discharge port and laycan, a set number of days before the laycan starts.
- The owner nominates the ship. Name, particulars and expected arrival, again by a set deadline. The owner may later substitute a similar ship if the contract allows it.
The owner's promise is to carry the cargo, not to use one particular ship. That is the main difference from a time charter.
A nomination is binding once it is sent. In an English case from 2008, the charterer nominated a laycan for the fifth of six shipments and then could not supply the cargo in time. It tried to move the laycan. The court held that the nomination became part of the contract when it was given, that the charterer could not keep some of its terms and drop others, and that the failure to perform was a serious breach. Check every nomination before it is sent.
Deadlines need exact wording. If the COA says "within one working day", a nomination sent after business hours is usually treated as received the next day. Define the working day, and write the time each nomination is sent into the record.
Spreading the shipments
A charterer would like to ship when its cargo is ready. An owner would like to know a year in advance where its ships will be. The spread clause balances the two. Words like "fairly evenly spread" cause disputes, because nobody agrees what fair means in a month with two holidays and a port closure. It is better to state a number of shipments per quarter or per month, and to say what happens to a shipment that is missed: carried forward, cancelled, or paid for as deadfreight.
A worked example
COA, illustrative figures only. Total quantity 600,000 mt coal, 10% more or less in charterers' option Allowed range 540,000 to 660,000 mt Period 12 months Shipment size about 55,000 mt, 10% more or less in owners' option Shipment range 49,500 to 60,500 mt Shipments needed 600,000 / 55,000 = about 11 Spread 3 per quarter, the last quarter 2
Two tolerances sit on top of each other: the charterer chooses the total, the owner chooses the size of each cargo. If the owner lifts the maximum every time and the charterer wants the minimum total, the programme may finish a shipment early. If the last remaining quantity is too small to fill a ship, the contract should say whether it is shipped as a part cargo, added to the previous shipment or settled in money.
COA, consecutive voyages and time charter
| COA | Consecutive voyages | Time charter | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ship | Owner chooses each time | One named ship | One named ship |
| Paid by | Tonne carried | Tonne carried | Day of hire |
| Who runs the ship | Owner | Owner | Charterer gives employment orders |
| Risk of delay at sea | Owner | Owner | Charterer |
| Who pays for fuel and ports | Owner | Owner | Charterer |
A COA is therefore a set of voyage charters under one umbrella. Laytime, demurrage and freight payment work as on any voyage charter. What the COA adds is the scheduling and the obligation to keep supplying cargo and ships.
The standard forms
BIMCO published its first standard COA for dry bulk, VOLCOA, in 1982. It was followed by GENCOA in 2004. In 2023 BIMCO replaced GENCOA with two forms:
- GENCOA A, a framework contract used together with a separate voyage charterparty for each shipment, so different trades can use their usual voyage form.
- GENCOA B, an all in one contract that contains both the COA terms and the voyage terms.
BIMCO's reason for a dedicated form is practical: parties who adapt a single voyage charter for a COA can end up cancelling the whole programme when they meant to cancel one shipment. Many large COAs, especially in tankers and in long term industrial trades, are still written on the parties' own terms. See charterparty forms.
The risks on each side
For the owner:
- If freight rates rise, the owner is still carrying at the COA rate.
- The owner must have a suitable ship at each laycan, even if it has to charter one in at a higher rate.
- A ship that misses its laycan can lose that shipment and lead to a claim.
For the charterer:
- If freight rates fall, the charterer is still paying the COA rate.
- If production falls short, the charterer may owe deadfreight or damages for the shipments it cannot supply.
- A nomination made in a hurry binds it to dates it may not be able to meet.
For both: a long contract runs into changes nobody priced: new emission rules, canal closures, sanctions. Clauses for force majeure, sanctions and cost changes matter more on a COA than on a single voyage, because there is more time for something to happen.
References
- BIMCO, GENCOA A 2022, 2022. bimco.org
- BIMCO, VOLCOA, 1982. bimco.org
- Steamship Mutual, Nomination notices under contracts of affreightment, 2008. steamshipmutual.com
- Steamship Mutual, Contracts of affreightment: nomination terms, 2007. steamshipmutual.com
- Handybulk, Contract of affreightment: meaning, GENCOA, cargo quantity and nomination explained. handybulk.com
Related
Neptune Atlas
Chartering software for a broking desk, covering the whole cycle: the world merchant fleet, position lists, cargo enquiries, fixtures, laytime and demurrage, and who to write to. Every paid plan starts with 7 free days. A card is needed to start them, and cancelling before they end costs nothing.
Try 7 days free Ship chartering software for brokers What each plan includes